Mar 7, 2017

Keel RepairThe types of keel damage that I see here at MarsKeel Technology are grounding damage, frost damage and corrosion of keel bolts with grounding damage being the most common. Grounding damage on fin keels is generally in the form of deformation from impact, bending damage, twisting damage or cracking. Most of the time there are multiple forms of damage on a single keel which can be attributed to the design of the keels with high aspect ratio keels being most susceptible to the entire range of damage types.

Conditions that effect the damage are the boat speed at impact, bottom conditions (rock, sand, etc.), the angle of impact (head on, glancing blow, etc.) plus the sectional area of keel. The challenge is if the keel didn’t “absorb” the impact energy, where did it go and what did it do when it got there?

It can all be started by a “simple” impact on the forefoot of the keel just, off centre line which can result in the fin being bent, twisted, warped, and cracked. This makes the assessment of the damage more complicated, trying to see if all those things are present or not, and proving it before a repair is started.

If it is not obvious you can spend a long time trying to definitively say that the keel is NOT damaged as the keel may look bent on the boat, but is it for example hanging perpendicular off the fair body? Is the keel on centre line? We use a combination of modern technology (eg. Lasers) plus old technology (eg. plumb bobs and straight edges and tape measures) to try to measure the damage which helps to remove what you think you see from what you are looking at.

Keel Repair 2Everyone has a perception of what they expect to see and this can get in the way of seeing what is there which is why we take our time setting up tools to define the damage and have several people from different areas look at it. It is common for us to have our plant manager (27 years’ experience), our lead fairing person (15 years’ experience) and myself look at the keel.

We all see the keel from different professional points of view and it is when these multiple observations are discussed and compared that we can best define the damage.

Once the damage has been assessed on the boat there is the immediate question of is it worth removing the keel to have it repaired? As you know removing a keel can be simple, if the hull keel joint is open and compromised, the keel almost falls off, or it can involve hours of slow, careful work and effort. During this time, there is always the risk of damage to the hull, keel bolts or the keel.

Now that the damage has been defined the next questions are,

1. Can it be repaired?
2. Should it be re-cast?
3. What is the cost?
4. How long will it take?

In the terms of more compound damage the questions and concerns over cost/ price and time get larger. Once the decision is made to consider a repair we need to know if the job can be physically done, and the price. It may be that the damage is sufficient to require a re-cast of the keel which may result in the least expensive, fastest, simplest and most successful outcome. The price for the effort needed to repair a keel may in fact be more than the cost of making a new keel. This process of course is only practical when the tooling is available or can be created.

On other occasions, it is not possible to recast and a repair is the only reasonable option.

The point is, life is never simple in the marine world. Just because we can repair something is it worth repairing?

By: William Souter, Chief Technologist
MarsKeel Technology® www.marskeel.com

 

Related Articles

Tuesday, 07 September 2021 11:38

It’s a scary thought - whether your boat is made of wood, fiberglass, aluminum or composite – it’s slowly deteriorating under you. Part of this is the nature of the marine environment: sun,...

Tuesday, 24 August 2021 11:53

It’s a scary thought – but whether your boat is made of wood, fiberglass, aluminum or composite – it’s slowly deteriorating under you. Part of this is the nature of the marine environment: Sun,...

Tuesday, 13 August 2013 11:25

Engines, accessories, spare parts and other metal equipment are susceptible to rust and corrosion even when well-protected. Premium shrink wrap supplier Dr. Shrink's new Multimetal ICT Film provides...

Monday, 26 March 2018 03:17

Most of us don’t give a second thought to our sacrificial anodes – those curious knobs of raw metal found on outdrives, shafts, rudders, and other metal components that dangle under the boat.

Monday, 24 March 2014 15:51

Understanding how systems really work – and degrade over the winter – can help you prepare your boat for a trouble-free season. Here’s a guide from a pro…Sometimes the most daunting thing about...

Thursday, 10 October 2013 15:20

When it comes time to haul out this year, plan to give all your underwater gear a close inspection, measure and replace your anodes now and know you are ready for next season. In the fall, you can...

Boat Reviews

  • Prev
Over the years Canadian Yachting has had the pleasure of doing several boat review articles on new ...
When J/Boats set out to make their latest model, their thinking moved away from a boat that you had ...
Wellcraft launched a legacy of offshore boats from Sarasota, Florida more than 60 years ago and ...
The well-known Four Winns brand is now a part of the international boatbuilder Groupe Beneteau and ...
Boats have been in high demand for the past two years and there’s no sign of this easing. ...
When we arranged to interview the designer and manufacturer to write a profile of the X Shore Eelex ...
I am lucky to have the opportunity to helm many types of boats. I am even more lucky to sail boats ...
The weather wasn’t cooperating for our test of the new Fountaine Pajot Isla 40. Rain, storm clouds ...
Last August, we were again invited to the Neptunus Yachts facility in St. Catharines, Ontario to ...
Cruisers Yachts’ 34 GLS is the latest model in the Cruisers Yachts line that includes a dozen ...

Video Gallery

Neptunus 650F

By Andy Adams

Over the years Canadian Yachting has had the pleasure of doing several boat review articles on new Neptunus models and we are familiar with the qualities that Neptunus is famous for. They have all been exceptional yachts, but this is the one I would most want to own myself. It’s a personal choice and a matter of taste as to whether you would prefer to have a sedan express model or a flybridge but in my opinion, the flybridge layout offers some wonderful attributes.

We met with Neptunus Managing Director Jan Willem De Jong this past fall to take the new Neptunus 650F out in Lake Ontario. 

Read More

Destinations

  • Prev
I sail on Lake St Clair. Michigan is on one side of the lake, and Ontario is on the other. My ...
The bright summer sun forces its way through magnificent Arbutus trees as I dive off our ...
I was first seduced by the United States Virgin Islands during a ferry ride from St. Thomas to ...
It was the last day of August and we were in Little Current heading south. Our Lasalle winter haul ...
Cowichan Bay is a waterfront village with a row of shops, artisan products, marine supplies and a ...
Instant towns have sprung up in the past, especially on the BC coast. In the late 1850s, Victoria ...
Following the War of 1812, a battle that Canada narrowly won against the United States, the ...
You’ve weathered COVID and you’re ready to book your charter to paradise. You’ve done some ...
If you are looking for an interesting destination for a weekend trip or longer, Quebec City will ...
A holiday often is defined by the experiences we make in unique and beautiful settings. But what ...

Sunset off St. John

By Mark Stevens

I was first seduced by the United States Virgin Islands during a ferry ride from St. Thomas to Tortola to begin one of our earliest British Virgin Islands charters nearly twenty years ago.

A perfect sunset off St. John with St. Thomas views for backdrop.

Clearing Pillsbury Sound, surrounded by voluptuous emerald mountains as the ferry sliced through royal blue waters, I was struck by the unspoiled ambiance of St. John, the island gliding past our starboard beam and the irresistible charm of a village called Cruz Bay visible from our quarter stern.

Read More

Lifestyle

  • Prev
Our Photo of the Week this time comes from our CY Team at FLIBS. Perhaps it’s the camera angle or ...
Yes, we are once again going to the dogs, a very popular and always welcome Photo of the Week ...
Last week Antonia and Georgia Lewin-LaFrance from Chester NS were named today Sail Canada’s Rolex ...
This week’s Photo of the Week comes from BC. The 99th Grey Creek Regatta was held at the Lakeview ...
Back in 2019 (I believe) your magazine used a pic of Sweet Love, a Ranger Tug 31, in a photo ...
a few shots of my wife Maggie practicing her silks routine on our 1982 C&C in the North Channel ...
Last issue, we took a look at boat names. Little did we know we would get what probably will be the ...
Boat names and puns go together like …. Well, like nothing else. Here’s a couple shared by our pal ...
Frequent Windsor racing contributor to Sailing in Canada Roger Renaud, caught this gorgeous ...
The Kingston Yacht Club (KYC) celebrated its 125th anniversary in the summer of 2021, in all the ...

DIY & How to

  • Prev
Last issue we explored NMEA 2000 networking, including the advantages of creating an on-board ...
The fungicide also acts as a biocide and prevents bacteria & fungal growth contamination from ...
Imagine a world where multiple touch-screens conveniently located will display information from ...
Last fall, a few members at my yacht club walked over and joined the exchange, which, by the way, ...
Boaters tend to be hands-on and active. Many (most?) like to launch and trailer our boats on our ...
We settled Svala into what my family and I had come to think of as the most desirable anchorage on ...
Never chartered? No problem. Here’s how to plan, execute and enjoy a vacation on a charter yacht ...
Once you’ve removed everything around and opened up all accesses to the engine and prop shaft, use ...
Most boaters are thinking about the end of the season at this time of year: prepping for haul-out, ...
Do you have abnormal engine vibration; rubber dust around engine mounts; telltale signs of possible ...

Svala at Anchor

Story and photos by Matt Bera

We settled Svala into what my family and I had come to think of as the most desirable anchorage on Lake Ontario, on a sunny summer afternoon. With an abandoned settlement, an old schoolhouse full of swallows, giant snakes and a rum-running past, Main Duck Island had it all.

That we had to sail past the Psyche Shoal, a magnetic disturbance, and into the middle of the rumoured Marysburgh Vortex made an even better sea story. It had taken us two attempts, two years, two boats and a new sort-of experimental engine to get there.

Read More

 

  

Sailing With a Captain

By Zuzana Prochazka

Never chartered? No problem. Here’s how to plan, execute and enjoy a vacation on a charter yacht where life is easy and the sunsets can’t be beat.

Decide on a crewed or bareboat charter

A crewed charter means you have a captain who manages the boat and maybe a chef or mate as well. Crewed charters ensure a safe and comfortable vacation with most everything done for you. The chefs are usually outstanding so if you’re a foodie, you’ll be in heaven and you may be able to pick up new recipes too. Larger crewed yachts may also have a mate who works with the captain and will do things like getting toys (kayaks, SUPs, snorkel gear, etc.) ready for you to use so you do very little work.

Read More

 

  

Marine Products

  • Prev
The world of marine electronics is just on fire in terms of development. You can almost name ...
On the water, most people store mobile devices in safe but relatively inaccessible spots. This ...
Many consider a tender a utilitarian means to an end—mere transportation. Argos Nautic's RIB ...
Internal mechanical marine tank sensors are plagued with problems that cause inaccurate readings. ...
When the weather turns ugly, how many of us contemplate just taking off, maybe forever. Long ...
Nothing is worse than going to the freezer to find that you’re out of ice. With a portable ice ...
For the skiers, wakeboarders, wakeskaters, or kneeboarders, the Kwik Tek Airhead Rope is a ...
Highly regarded by our readers as some of the best wine glasses for marine use out on the market ...
Teak accents and accessories are always a good idea. Keep your glassware safe with this appealing ...
The Hot Dog Banana Tube (aka “water weenie”) guarantees a summer full of laughter and fun.

News

  • Prev
Have you taken everything off the water already or are you still out there enjoying this amazing ...
On November 15th 2022, Mercury Marine, a division of Brunswick Corporation (NYSE: BC), introduced ...
Originally launched in 2022, Four Winns’ H-series’ success elevated the brand’s reputation as an ...
We couldn’t resist this promotional story and video from Yanmar. Thanks. Let’s enjoy the waterways ...
If you’re a first responder, work or just spend time recreating on or near cold water, this ...
SamBoat, already well implanted in Europe, is a boat rental platform that allows people to rent ...
West coast builder, Aspen Power Catamarans, has developed a new series of lightweight rigid tenders ...
The Four Winns TH36 Catamaran had its world premiere at the Cannes Yachting Festival, September ...
After borrowing boats for a couple of years, longtime J105 fanatic and many-year organizer of the ...
Due to ongoing mechanical issues, the Kirkfield Lift Lock will remain closed for the foreseeable ...

Mercury marine V10 OutboardsOn November 15th 2022, Mercury Marine, a division of Brunswick Corporation (NYSE: BC), introduced the industry’s first ever V10 outboard with the official launch of its all-new 5.7L 350 and 400hp Verado® outboard engines.
 
Consistent with the award-winning Verado brand, the new V10 engines are the quietest and smoothest in their class running 45 percent quieter than a leading competitor at cruise. In addition to NVH, the new Verado’s are not only compatible with the latest Mercury SmartCraft® technologies but will also be offered with an optional dual-mode 48V/12V alternator to seamlessly pair with Navico Group’s Fathom® e-power system, an integrated lithium-ion auxiliary power management system, providing boaters the opportunity to eliminate an onboard generator system.

Read More