altLots of Stakeholders in Lake Water Levels

In recent years low water levels on the Great Lakes have boaters and waterfront property owners looking for answers. North America’s Great Lakes hold about 18% of all the surface fresh water on earth and the Great Lakes Basin is home to some 40 million people. From these facts you can be certain of two things: 1) What happens to the lakes is incredibly important and 2) figuring out exactly what is happening to them is incredibly complicated. The 774,000 square kilometers of the Great Lakes Basin includes parts of eight US states and Canada’s largest province, ensuring that lots of different governments, agencies, and interest groups, all want to have their say.

In geological terms, the Great Lakes are relative newcomers, having been around in their modern form since the end of the last ice age, about 10,000 years ago. While near historic low water levels are alarming, it is important to keep things in perspective. We know from both historical and geographic evidence that water levels on the Great Lakes rise and fall all the time and for a wide variety of reasons. Sometimes the variation is much greater than what has been seen in recent times. Some 8000 years ago, during a very dry period, the lakes were about 200 feet lower and the major rivers flowing to the sea were dry.

The basic factors that affect water levels are obvious. Water enters the lakes from precipitation throughout the Great Lakes Basin and leaves through evaporation, consumption, diversion, and the St. Lawrence River. As is always the case, the devil is in the details. Longer term climate changes and even the rebounding of the earth’s surface after the ice ages all have an effect. Various parts of the lakes experienced low water levels in the late 1920s, the mid-1930s, and the mid-1960s. High levels occurred in the 1970s and extremely high levels in the late 1980s, followed by continuing high levels during the 1990s. It is possible that the relatively high water levels over the last 30 years have given many people the impression that these are the norm. The cyclical nature of water levels also makes it hard to discern the longer term patterns and what is causing the changes.

So Who’s in Charge?

In 1909, The US and Canada (actually Britain on our behalf) signed what may be the oldest environmental treaty in the world. The” Boundary Water Treaty” established the International Joint Commission (IJC) to prevent and hopefully resolve any disputes over water use along the border. The commission is responsible to approve any project that could affect water levels. It is this power that lead to the creation of the International St. Lawrence River Board of Control to manage outflows through the St. Lawrence Seaway system and through dams and power plants on the river.

The IJC manages outflow at various points in the lake system. The outflow from Lake Superior is controlled at the St. Mary’s River hydro dam and navigation canals. Lakes Michigan and Huron are basically one lake and their outflow is affected, but not controlled, by the St. Clair and Detroit rivers. Dredging of these rivers has had some effect on Huron and Michigan lake levels, but just how much is a controversial issue. It is believed by some that dredging on the river has lead to scouring of the river bottom thereby increasing the outflow of the lakes. This is the view taken by an advocacy group for property owners on Georgian Bay, however a recent study commissioned by the IJC has recommended that no action be taken regarding the St. Clair River. (See sidebar.) Lake Erie is controlled by the Niagara River power dam and the Welland Canal and finally the outflow of Lake Ontario is controlled by locks and dams on the St. Lawrence Seaway.

The International St. Lawrence River Board of Control held a public teleconference on March 16th where various stakeholders were invited to have their input for the coming season. Listening to the questions from property owners and boaters in the Thousand Islands region, it was easy to understand how the issue of water levels can be contentious. Where one group would like to see more allowance for natural variation, recreational boaters and waterfront property owners want stable water levels through the boating season. The board is a child of international agreements and has as its primary task the proper flow of water through the Seaway. Water levels at the port of Montreal are a primary concern. One caller, who pointed out the negative affect of international shipping to the lakes in the form of invasive species, asked if this might be stopped at some point in the future. While the person chairing the meeting merely pointed out that this issue was not under the board’s control, he could have been forgiven i
f he’d said “not bloody likely”. The vast sums of money spent on the Seaway for the express purpose of allowing ocean-going ships to access the Great Lake means that we can be certain no change is coming in this regard.

In the Short Term

For boat owners and waterfront property owners, it is not always easy to take the long view when seasonal variations, from erosion during high water to accidental grounding during low water, are affecting their pocket books. Although there are no tides on the lakes, the water level can experience rapid changes due to surge caused by strong or prolonged wind. All the lakes have this phenomenon but it is most pronounced in Lake Erie, the shallowest, where water levels at its eastern end have increased by as much a two meters in just a few hours. Once the wind abates the sloshing effect of the water moving back and forth (think of a bathtub), it is known as a seiche (pronounced “saysh). In winter, ice jams can also cause rapid changes and, if accompanied by high water, can cause considerable damage. In the early 19th century an ice jam on the Niagara River effectively dried the Falls for over a day.

Long Term

The issue of water diversion is a mixed bag. The water level on Lake Superior is augmented by diversions for hydro projects of rivers which originally flowed into James Bay. On the other hand the water diverted into the Mississippi river system through the Chicago Sanitary Canal has a negative affect on Lakes Michigan and Huron. With all the talk of the negative environmental effects of low water levels you’d think that the idea of diverting even more water from the Great Lake would be a non-starter. However rapid population growth in the dry regions of the US may also put pressure on the Great Lakes as plans to divert water are put forward. For the time being current legislation prohibits diversion out of the Great Lakes Basin. The results from human intervention so far should be enough to show that any large scale diversion could have disastrous effects and is something that Canada could be expected to vigorously oppose.

Climate Change

This is the big unknown, however, since we do know that water levels are affected by seasonal changes in precipitation and temperature, it stands to reason that long term changes to the weather will have a profound effect on the Great Lakes. Exactly what those effects will be is the subject of much debate. Although some projections indicate an increase in precipitation, this would be negated by an increase in evaporation due to higher temperatures. The more extreme scenarios speak of a drop of up to 8 feet by the end of the century, but a decline of less than half that amount could have a disastrous effect on wetlands, shipping, and boating, to say nothing of waterfront property values. The climate has been changing ever since the origin of the lakes at the end of the last ice age and if, as many believe, we are in for rapid changes in the near future, then we can be sure the lakes will feel the effect. Whether or not you believe the worst case scenarios, or even doubt climate change is real, what we do know
for certain is, with all the pressures of climate and population, careful stewardship of the lakes is more important now than it has ever been.

www.ijc.org
www.greatlakesdirectory.org
www.great-lakes.net

By Glen Cairns

 

Stakeholders Delivered a Clear Message to the International Joint Commission

Boaters, cottagers, marina owners, engineers and environmentalists were among those who delivered a clear message to the International Joint Commission in Midland in March.

Commissioners from the IJC were on hand to receive comments on a report by the International Upper Great Lakes Study Board. The Study Board focused on changes to the carrying capacity of the St. Clair River since 1962, examining factors such as sediment and erosion, scouring, glacial isostatic adjustment (the rise and fall of the earth’s crust following the ice age) and climate. It concluded that 70 per cent of the decline in water levels could be attributed to climatic factors such as precipitation, evaporation and runoff.

Apparently the Study Board found no evidence of erosion in the St. Clair River, at least since 2000 and in essence the report states although water levels in Lake Michigan and Lake Huron have declined in recent years, no remedial action is required.

That ‘do nothing’ attitude frustrated many who have repeatedly made their views known at previous IJC sessions. Although ideas differ on what type of water level controls should be constructed all agree measures need to be immediately implemented.

Mary Muter has monitored the water quality of Georgian Bay since the early 1990s and serves as the Georgian Baykeeper for Georgian Bay Forever, an advocacy group dedicated to protecting the bay’s unique aquatic environment. Muter said, “The commissioners have heard this before. It’s frustrating. When are they going to start to act? People are fed up saying the same things over and over again. In a perfect world they [the commissioners] would tell the Study Board to go back to the St. Clair River work and try remediation measures. The time to act is now.”

Brian Ramler agrees, calling it the ‘verge of a crisis’. Despite dredging twice in recent years Ramler is looking at lower than ever water at his Twin Bridge Marina in Waubaushene and his marina now has just 20 usable docks, down from his original 50. “Last year I said I needed two more feet of water to function properly, this year I need three feet more of water.”

Joe Hayward traveled from Craigleith to tell the IJC about phragmites, an invasive reed that grows to an astounding 12 feet or more, colonizing and obliterating the newly exposed shoreline.

Cottager Patsy Cross described how their water-access-only family cottage will soon be cut off completely as low levels in the channels dip further. “Soon our cottage will be worth nothing. You’re playing with people’s lives.”

After a lifetime spent on the bay and in business Ramler stated, “I don’t know if they realize how greatly it would affect our way of life here. Once it’s gone, it’s gone. We need to keep the water here longer. We have the chance to regulate the outflow.” He told the commissioners, “You have the power to make that happen.”

By Jennifer Harker
 

Related Articles

Boat Reviews

Video Gallery

 

 

Beneteau Oceanis Yacht 54By Zuzana Prochazka

Beneteau saw an opportunity to add a little thrill to any cruising adventure, so they took the hull of the First 53 racer (introduced just last year), and with a few fashionable changes, created the Oceanis Yacht 54, the new entry-level of Beneteau’s swanky Oceanis Yacht line. The result is a performance cruiser that sails like a witch and looks like a grande dame.

Design

Roberto Biscontini is the naval architect and Lorenzo Argento created the details of the exterior and interior design. 

Read More

Destinations

  • Prev
Over the course of four days in September 1864, representatives from Prince Edward Island, Nova ...
The new owners of L’Orignal Marina offer boaters a new destination. Located in a charming ...
On Friday, April 2 at 7 pm ET on TVO and streaming anytime after that on tvo.org and the TVO ...
Salt Spring Island, the largest among the Gulf Islands, has a certain mystique—much of it having to ...
Located in Lake Huron, the internationally significant Manitoulin Island is the largest freshwater ...
In Part I, Sheryl Shard ended the story at June and the start of Hurricane Season when they were ...
You likely aren’t quite ready to travel yet, but we have our fingers crossed that we can all fly ...

Riverest MarinaThe new owners of L’Orignal Marina offer boaters a new destination. Located in a charming francophone village in Eastern Ontario, this joined marina and restaurant venue is the ambitious initiative of long-time entrepreneur André Chabot and biologist Alexandra Quester, both residents of L’Orignal.

The purchase of the L’Orignal Marina was made official in November 2020. The new year was barely underway when all 50 available slips were already reserved. No wonder the addition of member and visitor slips is already planned for the 2022 season – the 2021 count is up to 62 power and sail already. At the moment, the Riverest Marina offers boaters a stop where they can launch their boat...

Read More

DIY & How to

  • Prev
It’s a scary thought - whether your boat is made of wood, fiberglass, aluminum or composite – it’s ...
It’s a scary thought – but whether your boat is made of wood, fiberglass, aluminum or composite – ...
Last summer there was tremendous interest in buying a boat to have fun in the restricted world ...
The boat buying or selling market is hot now and has been since the late spring of 2020. Sean ...
Last issue we got up with Montreal sailor Marc Robic who has accumulated a lot of tips and tricks ...
While some parts of the country are lucky enough to have year-round boating, there are plenty of ...
A Transducer is a device that is installed below the waterline that provides underwater data to a ...
Spring has finally sprung! At least it has weather wise here in Montreal, so it is with great ...
For most of us, the thrill of being aboard is associated with the motion of the water, wind in our ...
An important, but often overlooked maintenance item on any type of boat is it’s steering system. ...

Galvanic CorrosionIt’s a scary thought – but whether your boat is made of wood, fiberglass, aluminum or composite – it’s slowly deteriorating under you. Part of this is the nature of the marine environment: Sun, moisture, waves, wind, movement and vibration all contribute to components breaking down.

But there are other factors that are much more concerning and act at a significantly faster rate that the environment can take credit for. One of these is commonly spoken of, but not terribly well understood: Corrosion. As boaters, we’re concerned with two main types of corrosion: Galvanic and Stray-Current. This edition will focus on galvanic corrosion – in two weeks, stay tuned for info on stray-current.

Read More

 

  

Marine Products

  • Prev
Watermakers take ocean water and create perfect drinking water using reverse osmosis. A Schenker ...
If you’re headed out for a weekend afloat or on a week-long cruise you often must park your vehicle ...
Ten years ago, St. Margaret’s Bay (Halifax), Nova Scotia-based SailTimer Inc. made the first ...
Between the odor and working in confined spaces, replacing an onboard sanitation line is never a ...
For many boat owners who have gear to tote and the occasional stretch of bumpy road to negotiate, a ...
The 2022 Sea-Doo Switch is a re-imagined pontoon that makes hitting the water more accessible than ...
On the water audiophile-quality sound is attainable with the new JBL-R3500 source unit. The latest ...
An environmentally friendly product for refinishing your teak, hemp wood finishing oil is an ...
August means cruising, entertaining and enjoying summer at its finest. And that means food and ...
A Bluetooth-enabled phone or tablet is ideal for streaming music, but it's often stowed safely away ...

News

  • Prev
Royal Canadian Yacht Club’s Defiant completed a six-race sweep of the Cup for Canada over Zing, the ...
On September 6, Groupe Beneteau laid out its course to develop new boating experiences, new ...
Last Friday, the first ever Canada’s Celebration of Sailing honoured the season for Sailing in ...
Boating Ontario is very proud to have Transport Canada’s Office of Boating Safety jump on ...
Montreal-based Vision Marine Technologies, Inc. is headed to the Lake of the Ozarks Shootout to ...
Summer is in full swing with Canadians enjoying time outside and on the water. So, while enjoying ...
On July 23 last year, CYOB published a piece on a beautifully restored 1967 Trojan 42 Motor ...
HanseYachts AG presents RYCK, its third motorboat brand carrying the "Made in Germany" label. The ...
“We are all proud of our athletes and coaches who have dedicated themselves to push Canadian ...
Collingwood, ON hq’d Limestone Boat Company – owner and builder of Aquasport Boats, Limestone Boats ...

Mia and Caleb's EngagementOn July 23 last year, CYOB published a piece on a beautifully restored 1967 Trojan 42 Motor Yacht in Oromocto NB. (That piece was also expanded in CY magazine later in the year.)

One of our Canadian Yachting contributors, Denise Miller, had shared the article on my social media and a young man reached out and asked if she could connect him with the owners of the boat, Dave and Barb. Denise leapt into action and Dave and Barb were thrilled. They concocted a plan that the young lady, Mia, thought she was coming to model for a sales brochure for Dave to do charter tours.

Read More